What the brand claims
In the brand’s own words, quoted as written.
“H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen delivers intense, deep black pigment with a fine felt tip for precise, smudge-free lines that stay put all day. Formulated with vitamins to nourish the lash line, it resists water and sweat for a long-lasting, reliable finish.”
Quoted from the Elf product page
We quote these claims without judging them here — the verdict above weighs them against the evidence further down this page.
Ingredients15 ingredients
The full INCI list, as published by the brand.
Where to buy
What we've checked so far
We publish what we have while the assessment is still queued, and we're upfront about what's missing.
What we looked at
- Full INCI list, cross-checked against the brand's published formula.
- 90-day price history across 3 retailers, excluding shipping.
- 310 external ratings aggregated from review sites and retailers.
What we did not look at
- Our formula assessment — queued, not yet run.
- Shipping costs — not yet in all retailer feeds.
- Corol community reviews — none submitted yet.
What buyers say elsewhere
310 ratings from external review sites and retailers — scores only, we don't republish their words. Corol community reviews haven't started yet.
External average
4.2/ 5
310 ratings · not part of the verdict
Corol community reviews open here — be the first.
All 3 retailers
From €9.00 · Prices updated 1 day ago
° = over 3 days old